COVER

Table of Contents

EDITORIAL

COVER STORY

- United Colors of Jakarta

Reflections on the Asian-Latin American Lawyers' Conference

An Open Letter

COUNTRY SITUATIONS

 EAST TIMOR
- Confronting
 the past

 KASHMIR, INDIA
- Government cannot disregard human rights forever

Kashmir India - 
List of Disappeared

INDONESIA
 - After Suharto: A break in the cycle?

PHILIPPINES
- The parable of two streets

SRI LANKA
- Broken serendipity

THAILAND
- Wounded narratives


Excerpts from the Speeches and Paper Presentations Delivered During the Asian and Latin American Lawyer's Conference in Jakarta

Speech delivered Before the Asian-Europe People's Forum in South Korea
Between Memory and Impunity

STATEMENT
A Son's Disappearance: A Mother's Perseverance

FEATURE 
- Edcel Lagman:
A profile of courage

Contribucion Des De Latino America
FEDEFAM y AFAD unidas en Sola voz contra la desaparicion forzada

YEAR END REPORT



Country Situation
Thailand


Wounded narratives 
 

Ours is a world of dualities, universe fraught with contradictions. It is a plane where the borders between life and death are forever erased and diminished; where the godly and the diabolical are constantly dissolved in a fine mixture of flesh and bone. At the precise moment of recollection, our collective narrative takes on a dynamic all its own; transformed from an insipid and lifeless monochrome into a grand tapestry of colors and forms - a celebration of suspended movement, a recrudescence of infinite hue. In that vast canvas of Creation, every line and pigmentation is but the frozen moment of birth caught in the vise of asphyxia; an ancient wisdom commingled in the exuberance of youth; of full-grown maturity epitomized in the innocence of childhood. Reduced to a bare minimum, everything is a kin to the lingering shadow of the night made barren by the warm solace of candle light; or the crisp, smooth texture of a sheet of paper at the moment of contact with the sharp edge of a stylus nib. Caught in the whirlwind of polar opposites, the limitless cosmos becomes the scene of an unending tug-of-war between lightness and weight; novelty and decay; yin and yang, the inane and the sublime. For life - as the summation of contracts, of all that is dark and fair, passionate and dull - is but a replica of such duality. In a single individual existence, the synopses of two different lives are inevitably intertwined, gilded like that of the sun's unfolding light upon the earth's bright, morning sky.

Hence, for a mother, her life is but an extension of that of her child and mirror image of that of her progeny. It is an existence that is forever steep in mutual dependence, of constant emotional sustenance. Take the other and the narratives is no longer complete, forever torn asunder, unable to form a perfect whole.

And for Pasay, her life is a living testimony to such diaphanous yet tragic verity. For by the end of May 1992, she found her life suddenly malfigured and transfixed, losing her one and only son in a spasm of blood and violence at the behest of a faltering military regime.

A mother of three and the sterner half of long-failed matrimonial union, Pasay is one of those rare Thai women who is able to mix tenderness and resilience, meekness and fortitude. Already in her 60s and at the threshold of her sunset years, Pasay was born in a life of relative ease, with all the comfort and amenities inherent in the ways and norms of the middle class. Owning her own piece of real state house and a few possessions, her means and wherewithal  are surely beyond the desolate, with the thought of politics as the least of her concerns.

But in a country whose history has been marked by countless coups and counter-coups, of conspiratorial cliques and mass dissent, such a lifestyle of seeming unconcern is bound to end - sometimes in a state of daze, but more often through a process of rude awakening.

In mid-1991, in a style reminiscent of the 1970s, Thailand's duly-constituted civilian government was suddenly overthrown by the Army General Staff, wresting control of the most vital political institutions and keeping the population in a state suspense and frantic expectation. Proffering the usual justifications and alibis from putschists of all colors and stripes, the military promised to restore civilian authority in a year or so after the holding of general elections, and proceeded to the creation of an interim government, presumably for the purpose of transition.

But the Army, intoxicated by prestige and perks, soon reneged on its pledge and took command of the ill-dubbed National Peace keeping Council (NPKC) In an act of growing intransigence, coup leader and Army General Suchinda Kraprayoon assumed the premiership on the 7th of April 1992 despite his previous claims to the country, precipitating Thailand's most acute social political crisis in the past twenty years. Enraged by the Army's arrogance and lack of scruples, thousands of civilians took to the streets to demand Suchinda's ouster and the restoration of civilian rule. After the breakdown of the negotiations between a panic-stricken military and a large plethora of opposition parties, a crackdown suddenly ensued with the first shots of gunfire breaking out along the stretch of Ratchadamneon Avenue shortly after midnight of May 17. in its tragic aftermath, hundreds of demonstrators were shot dead and scores of others seriously wounded, while some remain missing and unaccounted for up to this day. Resulting in one of the most massive records of involuntary disappearance in recent memory, the Event of May 1992 has become one of the darkest stains in Thai history. According to the Ministry of Interior, 38 persons "disappeared" during the melee while other official sources record an additional 255 - a total of 293. And one of whom is Pasay's son.

Thrown into sudden fit of bewilderment and confusion, Pasay soon found herself scurrying through the city streets, looking for her disappeared kin. As her foray grew farther away from home, she began to spend the night in the open-air and sidewalks, with the night sky as her pillow.

As if losing a son was not enough, she even lost her earthly possessions due to her husband's innumerable vices. Misunderstood by her family and friends, she was soon abandoned by her two remaining children and became a semi-permanent fixture in the streets of Bangkok.

b  A parent with no permanent abode, she soon found some living quarters inside a Buddhist temple. Given a modest room and a small stove, she was assigned to clean a specific latrine inside the sacred compound and allowed to sell pieces of toilet paper and fish beads to the temple visitors. As a rule however, she was not allowed to keep the proceeds, though her lodging and other basic necessities were given to her free of charge.

Despite the temple's providing her personal haven for the past years, she still tried to commit suicide, due to her extreme sadness and perhaps, inconsolable loss. thank heavens for her fellow borders' alertness and constant concern!

In time, Pasay was given reparation, along with the other victims' of the May 1992 Event. Her estranged husband and children, however, wanted to have a share of the reparation but were justly denied, with the amount placed in a time deposit.

But still, Pasay continues to wait. For neither the temple monks' solitude nor the government's hollow consolations can bring her son back into her loving arms. Only justice can right a wrong and bring harmony to a mother's distraught existence.

Surely, order must be brought back in Thailand's distorted universe.

 

*****

In September 1999, in one of the plush halls of the Royal Plaza Hotel, a frail-looking man in retirable age took the microphone and narrated, in near-whispers, his personal loss in the Events of May 1992. In his recollection, punctuated by occasional pause and silent intervals, he disclosed the disappearance of his two sons and his frantic search for justice. Working in a government department that oversees the various religious institutions and which requires that its employees upon retirement be replaced by one of their children, the man who identified himself as Nippon, now has no one to succeed him.

Survived by his wife and daughter, he made a desperate attempt to find his missing offspring, roaming the capital in his old motorcycle to no avail. Emotionally overwhelmed, he decided to burn all his sons' memorabilia, sparing neither picture nor written records, as a way to assuage the pain and the enormity of their family's grief. Hence, with the current efforts to document every possible case, they do not have in their possession a single piece of certificate to bolster their claim.

In that same occasion, an old man in his 70's also spoke, stating that with only a few years ahead of him, his only wish is to see his disappeared daughter - dead or alive. If ever that will be granted, he would "have no qualms in closing his eyes in eternal slumber," he said.

Such stories for Adul Khiewboriboon, President of the Relatives Committee of the May 1192 Heroes, are the inchoate narratives that form the essence of their struggle. Apart from these testimonies are countless other narratives which remain unknown and undisclosed, due either to the refusal of the victims to share their painful experiences or to their inability to control their anger and grief. With no room for catharsis, they continue to be victimized, unable to take full possession of their lives. But to Adul and a host of others, it is these individual accounts that give impetus to their undertaking; and for the past eight years, these have given their campaign a sense of importance, despite government's inaction and increasing disinterest.

In 1999 for example, the Ministry of Defense commissioned a team to lead an investigation into the May 1992 democracy uprising. Headed by General Pichit Kullawanich, the team submitted its findings in a 600-page report. The Thai government, however, revealed only eight pages of the said document, despite the insistence of various civil society groups for its full disclosure. Unfortunately, even with the high hopes which the incoming administration of Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra has in abundance, Khiewboriboon remains unimpressed, acknowledging the new premier's lack of understanding of democracy and human rights issues.

Even before he could formally assume the country's much-coveted position, Thaksin has already managed to raise alarm signals with the resignation of Thepchai Yong, news editor of ITV - Thailand's most outspoken and critical television - after 41% of its shares were bought by the Prime Minister's Shin Corp. Democracy activists are now concerned that such a move could mean that from now on, Thai media would have to toe the line and give favorable reports  on Thaksin and his Thai Rak Thai Party. Moreover, the new Prime Minister seems unable to shake off charges of corruption and vote buying, allegation which are totally out-of-tune with his populist posture. This is further aggravated by the government's unwillingness to rehabilitate the victims and extend assistance in whatever form. Under these circumstances. the victims' quest for their long-awaited day of vindication may still be far from the offing.

Listen intently to the victims' painful narratives. They could very well be your own.


VOICE Maiden Issue 2001

 

Copyright 2008  AFAD - Asian Federation Against Involuntary Disappearances
Web Design by: www.listahan.org